Wk07-ScientificMethods2021T2
!”#$%&#’#”()$&*+,+-+./
COMP3511/9511 Human Computer Interaction
© Nadine Marcus @CSE, UNSW 2021
!”#$%&'()#*+,-./#0+’123
01$21#$3
4 56/#71-/.8-)-1#0/86(,
4 9/3/+’16#:3 ;3+<-=-8"#8/38-.>
4 ?@A/’-B/.8+=#,/3->.#(A8-(.3
4$5,#%.672$’$2$%”$6(‘+2(&*#6(3$$8
4 CD#EFGH#+.,#+=3(#I6#J
4 K/38/. LMNNMO##!”#$%&’&(#G##7//#I6+A8/’#M#
9/3/+’16#0/86(,3#-.#&3″16(=(>”
4$6$52″*(3#&*#%(5%(9:;(“+%&$<& 4 ?@+BA=/P#?:+=2+8-(.#()#+#./Q#3()8Q+'/# +AA=-1+8-(.#23/,#Q-86-.#+.#('>+.-R+8-(.G
4 71-/.8-)-1#9/3/+’16
9:;(=$6#.%(>2+”$66?(((@%5-+./(3#&*(
!”#$%&#’#”()$&*+,
?:+=2+8/%#####################S<3/':/%######################### 9/)-./########################$.+="3/ ?.:-3-(.% D/3->.
$-B3%##
I(.1/A82+=T
-R+8-(.
9/32=83%
I(.1=23-(.
0/86(,%
?@A/’-B/.83
A<>$2#B$%&5-(2$6$52″*(1$26C6(C6$2(
&$6&#%.
4 ;3/’#8/38-.>####L+AA=-/,#)(‘B#()#/@A/’-B/.8+8-(.O
U $-BP#5(#/:+=2+8/#23/’#A/’)(‘B+.1/#-.#(‘,/’#8(#
-BA'(:/#23+<-=-8"#,/3->.G
U 0/+32’/#8-B/#8(#1(BA=/8/#8+3V3#+.,#.2B/#(‘#+.3Q/’#+#
‘/3/+’16#W2/38-(.
U S<3/':/#'/=+8-(.36-A#GA6A
;3+<-=-8"#8/38-.>#:/’323#’/3/+’16
D65E#-#&/(&$6&#%.
4 CBA'(:/#A'(,2183
4 [/Q#A+’8-1-A+.83
4 9/32=83#-.)(‘B#,/3->.
4 ;32+==”#.(8#1(BA=/8/=”#
‘/A=-1+<=/
4 I(.,-8-(.3#1(.8'(==/,#+3#
B216#+3#A(33-<=/
4 &'(1/,2'/#A=+../,
4 9/32=83#'/A('8/,#8(#
,/:/=(A/'3
A<>$2#B$%&6(‘+2(2$6$52″*
4 D-31(:/’#V.(Q=/,>/
4 0+.”#A+’8-1-A+.83#L86+8#
‘/A’/3/.8#86/#8+’>/8#A(A2=+8-(.O
4 9/32=83#:+=-,+8/,#38+8-38-1+==”#
4 0238#=”#1(.8′(==/,#1(.,-8-(.3#
4 ?@A/’-B/.8+=#,/3->.
4 71-/.8-)-1#’/32=83#’/A(‘8/,#8(#
31-/.8-)-1#1(BB2.-8″
!&$>6(+'(&*$(!”#$%&#’#”()$&*+,
4 S<3/':+8-(.
4 ['+B/#+#6"A(86/3-3#LQ6+8#+'/#"(2#/@A/18-.>#8(#)-.,O
4 0/86(,(=(>”#8(#8/38#6″A(86/3-3#L38+.,+’,-3/,O
4 7/=/18#A+’8-1-A+.83#+.,#1(==/18#,+8+
4 D/31′-$6(+'(2$6$52″*
4 \+<('+8('"#/@A/'-B/.83 U ]->6#1(.8′(=X#<28#+'8-)-1-+=#/.:-'(.B/.8 4 ^2+3-T/@A/'-B/.83 U &+'8-+=#1(.8'(=X#.(#'+.,(B#+33->.B/.8
4 *(.#/@A/’-B/.83
U 9/+=-38-1#3/88-.>X#=-88=/#1(.8′(=#(:/’#/@8’+./(23#
/))/183#L-.1=2,/3#,/31′-A8-:/#_#1(”/=+8-(.+=#’/3/+’16O
4 $<(:/#=-38/,#-.#,/1'/+3-.>#(‘,/’#()#31-/.8-)-1#
‘->(2’X#<28#-.1'/+3-.>#=/:/=#()#A’+18-1+=-8″
!+B$(C6$’C-(,$’#%#&#+%6
4 ]”A(86/3-3#T 8/.8+8-:/#3#8(#
86/#/.8-‘/#A(A2=+8-(.#()####-.8/’/38############################################################################
!5B>-$(A<>$2#B$%&(G
4 ]”A(86/3-3#U !’236-.>#8//86#8Q-1/#+#,+”#Q-86#+#
)=2(‘-,/#8((86A+38/#Q-==#=/+,#8(#=/33#,/.8+=#
1+:-8-/3
4 ?@A/’-B/.8+=#1(.,-8-(.##:3G#1(.8′(=
4 D+8+#1(==/18-(.
U ](Q#B+.”#323
;B>+2&5%&(‘5″&+26(&+(“+%6#,$2
4 I(.8′(=#()#/@8’+./(23#)+18(‘3##
U ?>G#;3/’ 3#=/:/=#()#/@A/’-/.1/X#]+Q86(‘./#/))/18X#
S’,/’-.>#/))/18
4 I(.8′(=#()#<-+3/3#
U 7+BA=-.>X#/@A/’-B/.8/’
U D(2<=/#<=-.,#3/82A#1+.#+2&5%&(‘5″&+26(&+(“+%6#,$2
4 9/=-+<-=-8"#T 1+.#86/#3+B/#'/32=83#+-.#Q-86#86/#3+B/#32#Q6+8#”(2#
6(A/,#8(#B/+32’/c
4 *//,#+#1(.3-38/.8#+.,#’/A/+8+<=/#A'(1/,2'/
4 7->.-)-1+.1/#=/:/=#T ](Q#1/’8+-.#+’/#”(2#86+8#
“(2’#’/32=83#Q/’/#.(8#(<8+-./,#<"#16+.1/c
A<>$2#B$%&5-(,$6#.%6
4 D-))/’/.8#A+’8-1-A+.83#T 3-.>=/#>'(2A#()#
A+’8-1-A+.83#-3#+==(1+8/,#’+.,(B=”#8(#86/#
/@A/’-B/.8+=#1(.,-8-(.3G
4 7+B/#A+’8-1-A+.83#T +==#A+’8-1-A+.83#+AA/+’#-.#
<(86#1(.,-8-(.3G
4 0+816/,#A+'8-1-A+.83#T A+'8-1-A+.83#+'/#B+816/,#
-.#A+-'3X#/G>GX#<+3/,#(.#/@A/'8-3/X#>/.,/’X#/81G#
D-))/’/.8X#3+B/X#B+816/,#
A+’8-1-A+.8#,/3->.
=#”$2$%&(,5&5(“+–$”&#+%(&$”*%#HC$6
Technique Reactivity Face
Validity
Control Measure
detail
Task
analysis
Zero High — —
Observations Low High Zero Low
Surveys Medium Medium Low Medium
Experiments High Low High High
!CBB52/
4 $.+=(>”#()#71-/.8-)-1#0/86(,#Q-86#]IC#D/3->.#
&'(1/33
4 ;3+<-=-8" 8/38-.> :3 ?@A/’-B/.8+=#’/3/+’16
4 ?@A/’-B/.8+=#9/3/+’16
U 5″A/3#()#’/3/+’16#
U [+18(‘3#8( 1(.3-,/’
U ?@A/’-B/.8+=#D/3->.3
U D+8+#1(==/18-(.#8/16.-W2/3